I dont have any opinions about these but this can and might help a little Compare Phones (Phone Scoop)
Well, they are both pretty close. The 8600 is more music friendly. It also gets good reception. Not as good as an KRZR, but close. The 8600 in my opinion has a better quality feel to it. I wish I had more experience with the samsung before I could honestly declare one the best of the two.....The RAZR 2 is coming out in mid September I believe, but it will be something like 249.99 with a 2 year contract like all the other carriers, so I don't know if you want to pay that much. It will end up being better then the sammy and the lg, baring any major unknown factory/software defects.
I am not a big fan of the Razr. I like a phone where the number keys are raised up slightly. When I hold the LG AX8600 and the Hue the LG feels heavier and more solid. I have not made a call from either phone so I can't say how they work.