Poll: Will you get an Android phone?

I will probably go Android with my next upgrade. I do not like the path Windows Mobile is taking.

 

I'm debating between the Droid Incredible and the next iPhone (whether it comes to Verizon or not). The Incredible's looking really good, but I'm still going to wait a few months to see what happens.

 

I would certainly consider it.

But the first manufacturer to bring a phone that supports both at&t and T-Mo 3G would get my business next - regardless of operating system or probably even phone features. And I really have no intention of buying another "nice" phone until that happens.

 

I'm pretty much in the same boat. I don't care too much about the OS inside the phone — it's the hardware that is more critical for me. Right now I'm perfectly happy to wait for some HSPA 850/900/1700/1900/2100 phone to become available. According to GSM arena N8 has all five bands but I'll believe it when I see it

 

I have had a T-Mobile G1 (aka "Dream") for a few months now. It was the cheapest Android phone I could find on ebay ($250 or so). I got it half out of curiosity for Android and half because I plan to develop a Cellumap app for Android and needed a phone for that. I'll maybe pick up a Motorola Milestone (GSM version of the Droid) if the prices come down on it this summer.

Android is a nice OS, but is still a little rough around the edges, and going thru new releases faster than hardware mfgs can keep up with; for example: SonyEricsson X10 just came out with OS 1.6, while OS 2.1 has been available for a few weeks/months already. Hard for developers to keep up with too. But I think it's only a matter of time (maybe not even that much time) before Android becomes the dominant OS.

One reason I like Android is because it's "free and open" and available on several different devices. The only other OS I can think of that matches that would be Symbian. Symbian is in some ways a better OS (more developed and mature) but it's getting kind of stale and needs some revamping (doesn't have the momentum that Android has). ...and personally, from developing my Cellumap app for Symbian, I can say the signing process to allow apps access to GPS and cellular info is extremely painful and works against developers. ...and really for an OS to succeed these days, well, we all know it's all about apps

 

I am considering upgrading to Android when the Verizon account is eligible during the third week of November. BlackBerry is nice but Android definitely has my eye. I will be debating between BlackBerry and Android when I am eligible later this year.

 

I may get one when I move to Englnd next year. I am not sure thought. I just my unlock my wifes iPhone (ATT) and use it with ASDA mobile. (Walmart owns them)

 

Already have mine. And just about comfortable enough with it to start upgrading to a leaked OS. I'm betting I'll like it even more then!

 

I'd have to change my plan and give up my old grandfathered deal so no dice for me.

 

I had to put 'NO' for the time frame of the question: in the next 12 months.

I don't see any real significant reason to go Android over the iPhone. I'm happy with ATT and the iphonw does all that I need (and more in about one month with OS4)...I don't see anything of major interest with going Android or should I say different. The android is just trying to be an iPhone, and I have one already. ( no arguments please... but this is really the case, isn't it?) . The iPhone integrates very smoothly with my Mac laptop, PLUS I do like iTunes, and the ability to Shazam a song, and then buy an iTunes version right to the phone.

This is especially true when I consider the 70 useful application that I currently have on the iphone...while many are free or low cost...changing them to, hopefully equivalent android ones, is only a lot of work without any real benefit.

 

I bought a myTouch 3G LE in January. It didn't take long for me to get very comfortable with the OS. With all the apps and widgets available I can make Android fit my needs easily and without spending a lot either. And of course it hands syncing with gmail very well, along with calander and contacts. I like not having to use Outlook any more. Granted their is exchange on with WM, but it's not nearly as good. Being that I like WM and love flashing ROMS on my devices, I thought I would be chomping at the bit to root and flash ROMS on Android. That is not the case Android just works, which is what impressed me the most about the OS. I will be getting the next Nexus One type device for T-Mobile to replace my myTouch which does lack in the sound quality/loudness area.

 

Let's not open that can of worms shall we? But no, I'd say Android is everything Apple isn't. Apple is very constrained, while Android is open and free. For ex: if you have Verizon, no chance of an iPhone. Or if you don't like touchscreens and want a physical keypad ala Droid, no chance with Apple. And as for developers, with Apple, all apps must be submitted to their store for approval, while Android apps can be downloaded from anywhere.

...ok, let's stop it there and not hijack/derail this thread.

 

So why did you respond? It is my opinion All phones or carriers have constraints. Not all Android devices are equal. They are not as free and open as many think. One gets a glimpse of that by playing with it and reading reviews (i.e. MS ActiveSynch lacking).

Verizon is constraining and as of yet does not have an android GSM/UTMS phone. A big constraint for the world traveler. And Verizon does not give me voice and data at the same time (3G)

The closest full multi-touch screen (and not fully MT) is the Nexus One, but there is no keyboard there.

And if one wants an iPod in the phone, the android's music player is lacking as a good iPod. It's Okay, but not an iPod. This is the opinions from reviewers.

For software, I haven't tired of my Apple endorsed options there quite yet. And all developers have to follow rules and management approvals (except for the lone developer...which, no thank you, not on my device).

So for the next 12 months, I see nothing overwhelming to entice me quite yet. For me its the OS and the hardware design that flirts with me. Not an interesting OS in a clunky device.

For the majority of consumers, that are stuck or wish to be on Verizon or must have a physical keyboard or must have a officially unlocked GSM phone, or just hate Apple, an android is a good choice that gives the majority of features that people envy/desire in the iPhone concept. That was the point of my comment.

Choosing any phone requires some compromise with carriers and the phone. But for me, being happy with ATT global service, liking the virtual keyboard, loving UTMS 3G, a true iPod, and who never uses local sims when I roam globally, the iPhone has it all. That is why I answered the question, NO, not in the next 12 months.

No further comments...keep this thread on topic!!! :deadhorse

 

I think you are stuck in a gear that only sees other phones as wanting to emulate the iPhone. I don't see it as such. Especially with Android, the model is very different. Apple gets it's $ by selling hardware as well as software (via their app store). Google is mainly about advertising via ads in search results, Gmaps, Gmail, etc. and Android is a vehicle for that. Given that, it's in their interest to get it on as many devices as possible. I see it closer to Symbian than any other OS actually.

And generally speaking, there needs to be a consolidation, or at least more of a commonality between phones OS's in order to keep phone app development going smoothly. When someone develops an app today, they need to re-build it 10x over, one for each OS (RIM, Apple, Android, WinMob, etc) Ok, JME gives some commonality at least, but not always. I think if one OS became dominant (the way Windows is for PC's) then everyone would benefit from that. Android has the backing and momentum, and has a "open and free" approach, so I'd really like to see it succeed.

 

I marked "Possibly/I am considering one". I am not positive that I will make the 12 month window. At this time AT&T does not have a device that appeals to me but the Android OS definitely does and in today's world new devices come out every day.

I am suitably impressed by the "Incredible". It has great specifications and very positive reviews, hopefully there will be an "incredible" like GSM device with a minimum of 850/1900/2100 3G in the not too distant future.

 

Since my polite, non abusive OP to your comment (to stay on topic) was removed by a SuperMod, I'll comment more fully. Seriously!

I couldn't disagree more strongly. Most phone mgfr want to be the iPhone Killer (i.e. emulate as much as possible to be as successful and hopefully, one better than Apple). And that is what most consumers are looking for too. I doubt anyone is buying an Android to help Google make more money with ads, and their gmail, gmaps, google search is already on most cross platforms.

You really think having one OS is more innovative? Symbian as an example? Seriously? I doublt many Apple haters would feel that way if it was Apple's OS that was the dominant OS. You are right, Android may dominate eventually (since current mgfr don't know how to write software for smartphones), but Apple broke the staid mold phone mgfr were sitting in!

 

Please note that the the topic of this thread is a a poll "Will you get an Android phone? " It was not a discussion on comparing OS or who wants to clone who. If anyone wants to have such a discussion, please start a new thread in the "General Wireless Forum" .

From now on, all posts not pertaining to the original topic, will be deleted. Please keep the thread on-topic..

Thank you.

 

Wirelessly posted (T-Mobile G1: Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; U; Android 1.6; en-us; T-Mobile G1 Build/DMD64) AppleWebKit/528.5+ (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/3.1.2 Mobile Safari/525.20.1)

I'm a happy Android user and I still like my G1, although I've had it for amost 14 months. It has its flaws, but most of the things that people dislike about it don't bother me. A phone would have to be very good to replace it. It would have to be on T-Mobile, the carrier I've found to be the least horrible. That's why I've been posting about the upcoming myTouch 3G Slide. If the reviews are good and I find the keyboard useable, that could be my next phone.



SW

 

Thank you Charlyee!

 

I couldn't wait for Sprint to stop dragging their heels on the 2.1 update, so I rooted my phone and flashed to 2.1. I am quite happy I did so.

 

Can't wait to hear how you like 2.1 and how it compares to 1.5/1.6. I'm still waiting for a safer & easier way to root my myTouch, and for some fully functional ROMS.

 

I am SOOOO leaning towards the Droid Incredible right about now...:drool:

Time will tell.

 

I keep reading the Incredible reviews - torturing myself. Wonder if I can talk them into swapping...

 

Absolutely not!! I will be sticking with the Apple iPhone.…

Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 3_1_3 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/528.18 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/4.0 Mobile/7E18 Safari/528.16

 

Based on currently available information it seems like Microsoft has decided to follow in Apples foot steps by creating a walled garden of their own. This means their is only one platform left where the user has any genuine choice about what they want on there mobile device Android.

I looking froward to switching to android as soon as my contract is up.

 

No. Very satisfied with iPhone.

 

Yes even a jailbroken Iphone/Ipod Touch is still more restrictive than an Android handset.

 

I know I said absolutely not, however, after seeing the reviews, and pictures of the HTC Desire that will be coming to AT&T within a month or two, I am having second thoughts. :cool2:

Pictures: HTC Desire

 

After you have android you wont go back!!!!!