MUST you have a data or texting plan now to get a decent device?

Unfortunately yes. The carrier's logic is that these phones are designed for data use and because of this, it must have data plan.

I'm with you on this. I don't want a crappy, low-end phone. I'd rather use the phone of my choice and block data if I choose too. Sadly, the carriers care about one thing - MONEY. They are a business and this is how they choose to run it. It's not always right, but it is what it is.

Your only other choice is to go with a local/regional carrier (if available) who might be more allowing with not requiring data plans on smartphones. Of course there's no guarantee of this, but it might be worth finding out about.

The reality is, if you want service with the big 4, and you want a smartphone, a data plan is mandatory. It is what they require as part of their service.

 

What does AT&T charge for MEdia Net now?

As was the case when I had service with them several years ago (as Cingular), MEdia Net was simple, basic web browsing with a regular phone, nothing extravagant.

 

You can get Quick Messaging Devices from AT&T which require only a messaging plan of at least $20.00. This would cover unlimited messaging. See this link for models: Packages & Deals List - Shop - Wireless from AT&T
You might have to enter your Zip Code to reach that webpage.

 

when i upgraded a while back i had only a handful of phones to choose from. I was pretty irritated with the choices and their business practice.