Analysis: After BellSouth, Is Anyone Left? After a decade of dealmaking, the phone industry is running out of buyers and sellers. The latest deal, AT&T Inc.'s agreement on Sunday to buy BellSouth Corp. for $67 billion, would remove one of the few major targets left in the phone business. BellSouth, the dominant local carrier in the South, was arguably the best-managed phone company in the United States. Its key asset, though, was its 40% stake in the fast-growing Cingular Wireless, the nation's biggest wireless phone provider. Since AT&T owned the other 60%, it made perfect sense that those companies were most likely to merge next. Industry analysts have been predicting such a move for several years. If BellSouth is removed from the picture, the most attractive takeover candidate would probably be Sprint Nextel Corp. Other promising targets could include Alltel, T-Mobile or even Qwest Communications International. Stocks for all those companies rose in Monday trading. Beyond those companies, the pickings are slim. Most major phone companies already have been snapped up -- the most recent being the old AT&T Corp., MCI Inc. and Nextel Communications Inc. Some of the potential targets, however, could present regulatory, technological or financial hurdles and may not come to fruition. Take Sprint. After its acquisition of Nextel this past summer, Sprint solidified its spot as the third-largest wireless firm in the United States, with expected revenue of more than $46 billion in 2006, according to analysts' estimates compiled by Thomson First Call. The Nextel deal reduced the number of national wireless carriers to just four from six a few years ago. Yet any deal that cuts the number to three would certainly face intense scrutiny. Regulators would be particularly wary of a deal involving Sprint and the No. 1 and No. 2 wireless carriers, AT&T Inc. and Verizon Communications. As it stands now, only Verizon could be considered a possible suitor. AT&T will be busy integrating BellSouth, and then there's the technological hurdle: Cingular Wireless, owned by AT&T and BellSouth, runs on a different standard of transmission than Sprint Nextel. Solving the problem could cost a bundle. Verizon is technologically compatible with Sprint, but the former company has its sights set on acquiring full control of its own wireless business. Vodafone Plc (VOD) owns a 45% stake in Verizon Wireless, the No. 2 mobile operator in the United States, and it will cost tens of billions of dollars to buy off the U.K.-based wireless concern. "We are focused on integrating MCI, divesting our directories business and working to acquire from Vodafone the remaining 45% of Verizon Wireless," the company said in a statement Monday. If and when that transaction takes place, T-Mobile could become a potential target. The company, owned by Germany's Deutsche Telekom, is the smallest of the four national wireless carriers in the United States. To its advantage, T-Mobile uses the same GSM wireless standard as Vodafone. As a result, Vodafone could quickly regain a foothold in the key U.S. market if it sold its stake in Verizon Wireless. In the meantime, it's always possible that Verizon could cast a glance at Alltel Corp , the Arkansas-based wireless carrier that mostly targets rural areas and midsized cities. Alltel actually covers more territory with its wireless network than any other carrier, although there are fewer people living within its coverage area. Later this spring, Alltel plans to spin off its local telephone business as in independent company -- turning itself primarily into a mobile operator. 'I can't imagine why anyone would want to buy Qwest.' Nancy Havens, Havens Advisors While its wireless business is expanding rapidly, Alltel's traditional phone business has stagnated. The result of the spinoff, not surprisingly, will make Alltel a more compelling target to Verizon. The companies use the same CDMA wireless transmission standard and have a longstanding roaming or network-sharing deal in place. Of all the potential targets, Qwest might be the least attractive. The company does not own a wireless business, hasn't made money in several years and still owes more than $14 billion in long-term debt. The Denver-based company also has a more expansive and costly territory to serve: 14 Western states with far-flung populations. "I can't imagine why anyone would want to buy Qwest," said Nancy Havens, president of Havens Advisors, a hedge fund in New York. In light of its predicament, Qwest could be an acquirer. Chief Executive Richard Notebaert has consistently said that his company would look to buy discounted assets from big carriers such as AT&T and Verizon when they seek regulatory permission to acquire other phone companies. As with Verizon's recent acquisition of MCI Inc., Qwest can be expected to lobby Washington to force AT&T and BellSouth to spin off some of their assets to win approval for their deal.
Sprint Nextel, while smaller and #3, to me would seem an unlikely plausible takeover candidate, if for not other reason than they have nationwide wireless presence/spectrum and a nationwide landside infrastructure to back it up, and as such are a viable competitor to Verizon and AT&T. I would not think the regulators would ever allow it.
T-Mobile is owned by Deutsche Telekom AG and they have already announced that T-Mobile USA is not for sale.
My money is on ALLtel or US Cellular. Verizon will get one of them. Sprint is to busy buying out nextel partners. That is why they are getting rid of the landline business to pay for their purchases.
I would hope that Verizon would not be allowed to buy Alltel. That would create too big of a monopoly.
According to a Forbes article Alltel is unlikely to be taken over soon. Below is a link to the article. http://www.forbes.com/technology/wireless/2006/03/08/alltel-verizon-sprint-0308markets10.html?partner=rss
Alltel/US Cellular or Alltel/T-Mobile would have no trouble getting approval by the feds. But anything bigger than those could and should be an uphill battle.
I also doubt that ALLTEL will be bought out anytime soon. I think they are doing very well on their own, and I do hope they are not eaten by anyone. ALLTEL taking over US Cellular is something I could see happening, but I think there would be some overlap in assets. ALLTEL/US Cell would make a good match IMO, though.